Everybody has been to a wedding where the toasts tell four different stories about the same couple. The best man talks about the road trip. The maid of honor talks about the night they met. The dad tells a story nobody else knew, and the college roommate tells one the bride wishes he hadn't. Same couple, same night, four very different speeches.
That's a good place to start if you want the Gospels explained. The Gospels are the four books that open the New Testament, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, and each one tells the story of Jesus' life, teaching, death, and resurrection. They are ancient biographies of Jesus. Written by people who believed he was who he said he was, for communities who needed to know it too.
If you grew up in church, though, you may have been handed the Gospels as one smooth, seamless story. Read them side by side and the seams start to show. In John, Jesus clears the temple near the start of his ministry (John 2). In the other three, it happens in his last week. Matthew has Jesus teaching on a mountain (Matthew 5 to 7), and Luke has something very close to it on "a large, level area" (Luke 6:17). For some people that's a fun puzzle. For others, it's the first crack in the wall.
Here is what I believe. Once you know what kind of books the Gospels are, and why each one was written, those differences stop feeling like a threat and start making a lot of sense.
What Are the Gospels?
The word gospel comes from the Greek εὐαγγέλιον (euangelion), and it means good news. In the Roman world, euangelion was the kind of word used for a big public announcement, a victory in battle or the birth of a new emperor. Mark opens his book with it.
"This is the Good News about Jesus the Messiah, the Son of God." (Mark 1:1)
The early church took that word and attached it to the books themselves. The titles we know, "The Gospel according to Matthew" and the rest, were added later, by the second century at the latest. Which is why we call them the Gospels. Each one is the good news about Jesus, according to someone.
So what kind of book is a Gospel? For most of the last century, scholars treated them as their own unique thing with nothing to compare them to. Then in 1992 New Testament scholar Richard Burridge published a book asking the same question this section does, What Are the Gospels? He compared the four Gospels to Greek and Roman biographies, what the ancients called bioi (lives), and found they fit that category pretty well. His view has become the majority view since.
That matters, because an ancient biography doesn't work like a modern one. A modern biography of Abraham Lincoln will tell you about his childhood, his law practice, his marriage, his famous beard, and probably his shoe size. An ancient one picked the stories that showed who a person really was, arranged them by theme as often as by date, and spent a lot of time on how the person died, because the death said something about the life. Mark spends six of his sixteen chapters on the last week of Jesus' life, and an ancient reader would have expected exactly that.
Side note: you may have heard about other gospels, like the Gospel of Thomas or the Gospel of Mary. A full copy of Thomas turned up in Egypt in 1945, and it's a collection of sayings with no story of Jesus' death or resurrection. Most scholars date it to the second century, and both texts are often linked with Gnostic groups, though how "Gnostic" Thomas really is gets argued about. The early church didn't use them as Scripture. When the historian Eusebius wrote his Church History in the early 300s, he listed gospels going by the names of Peter, Thomas, and Matthias as the work of heretics and called them "absurd and impious." Dang, that's harsh. But the four we have were settled long before anyone wrote out a full list of New Testament books, and (spoiler) Constantine didn't hand us the Bible either.
Who Wrote the Gospels?
Strictly speaking, none of the four Gospels signs its name. The authors we know come from the early church, mostly from two writers. Papias, a bishop writing in the early second century, said Mark wrote down what Peter taught (we only have his words because Eusebius quoted them). Around the year 180, Irenaeus named all four: Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. Those names have stuck for good reasons.
Matthew was a tax collector named Matthew who left his booth to follow Jesus (Matthew 9:9) and became one of the twelve. Mark, also called John Mark, was a companion of Peter, which is why people have long read his Gospel as Peter's testimony (Peter even calls him "my son" in 1 Peter 5:13). Luke was a physician (Colossians 4:14) who traveled with Paul and wrote both the Gospel of Luke and the book of Acts. John is tied to "the disciple Jesus loved," who is named as the source behind the fourth Gospel (John 21:20 to 24). Irenaeus identified him as John the son of Zebedee. Some scholars think the beloved disciple was someone else, and that conversation is still going.
Why write any of this down? For the first few decades, the story of Jesus mostly traveled by word of mouth. That sounds shaky to us, like a game of telephone. Kenneth Bailey, who spent decades living and teaching in the Middle East, describes how village communities told and retold important stories with the whole group listening, and anyone who got the key details wrong was corrected on the spot.
But as the church spread into the wider Roman world and the eyewitnesses got older and started to die, people needed something more permanent. Luke tells us exactly why he wrote.
"Many people have set out to write accounts about the events that have been fulfilled among us. They used the eyewitness reports circulating among us from the early disciples. Having carefully investigated everything from the beginning, I also have decided to write a careful account for you, most honorable Theophilus, so you can be certain of the truth of everything you were taught." (Luke 1:1 to 4)
Most scholars date Mark to around 65 to 70, Matthew and Luke a decade or two after that, and John to around the 90s. Mark is widely believed to be the first, with Matthew and Luke using him as a source. Matthew reuses most of Mark, often word for word. Matthew and Luke also share a lot of teaching that Mark doesn't have, and many scholars think they drew it from a second source they call Q (from the German Quelle, "source"). Nobody has ever found a copy of Q, though, and some scholars, like Mark Goodacre, argue Luke simply used Matthew. If you want to get in the weeds on why Matthew, Mark, and Luke overlap so much, that's a whole conversation on its own.
Why Are the Gospels Different?
So, back to the wedding. Nobody at that wedding thinks the best man or the dad is lying. They know the couple from different angles, and each one is talking to the room in front of him. The Gospels work the same way.
Matthew writes like someone talking to Jewish readers. He traces Jesus' family back to Abraham, groups Jesus' teaching into long sermons, and over and over he tells you something happened to fulfill what a prophet said. For Matthew, Jesus is the Messiah Israel had been waiting for.
Mark is short and in a hurry. He uses the Greek word for "immediately" over forty times, and Jesus is always on the move. He also stops to explain Jewish customs (Mark 7:3 to 4) and translates Aramaic words for his readers (Mark 5:41), which tells us a lot of his audience wasn't Jewish. Early tradition places him in Rome, writing for a church that knew what it meant to suffer.
Luke writes to Theophilus, a Greek name, and he traces Jesus' family all the way back to Adam (Luke 3:38). He keeps putting outsiders in the spotlight: shepherds, widows, Samaritans, tax collectors, and a lot of women. For Luke, Jesus is good news for everybody.
John is the one that feels different the moment you open it. "In the beginning the Word already existed. The Word was with God, and the Word was God." (John 1:1) He spends more time in Jerusalem, gives us long conversations instead of short parables, and tells us his purpose plainly near the end.
"But these are written so that you may continue to believe that Jesus is the Messiah, the Son of God, and that by believing in him you will have life by the power of his name." (John 20:31)
Are you seeing the connection yet? Each writer chose and arranged his stories to help a real group of people see Jesus clearly. John wants you to know who Jesus is from the first pages, so he puts the temple scene up front, and an ancient biographer would have been fine with that. The four Gospels aren't four witnesses who can't get their stories straight. They're four portraits of the same face. Around the year 180, Irenaeus argued it was fitting that there were four, like the four winds or the four corners of the earth, because the good news was meant to go everywhere.
How Should We Read the Gospels?
Don't rush to stitch every detail together. When you notice a difference, ask a better question. Why did Luke tell it this way? What did John want his readers to see by putting this scene here? Usually the difference is where the writer is trying to teach you something.
Read one Gospel all the way through, on its own, before you start comparing. Mark can be read in a single evening. Pay attention to what each writer keeps coming back to, the themes and words that repeat. And learn a little about the first century world they lived in, because the more you know about Rome, the temple, and life in Galilee, the more the stories open up.
It also helps to read the footnotes in your Bible. They'll tell you where the oldest manuscripts differ, like with the story of the woman caught in adultery, which most of the earliest copies of John don't include. Honestly, that's just part of how these books were copied and passed down, and it's good to know.
If you're not sure where to begin, I'd start with Mark. It's short and it moves fast, and it opens with that one word. I wrote more about what Mark means by good news if you want to go a little deeper.
I don't assume I've answered every question you have about the Gospels. People much more educated than me have spent their whole lives on them. But I do hope you see them a little differently now, as four people, who knew Jesus or knew the ones who did, each standing up at the table to tell you who he is.
Four toasts, one groom.
So, which Gospel are you going to read first this week, and what do you think its writer most wanted you to see about Jesus?