Matthew the Tax Collector: Why Jesus Chose a Traitor

Most of us know what it feels like to be on the wrong side of the room. You walk into a place and figure out pretty quickly that you aren't the kind of person they had in mind.

Matthew knew that feeling better than most. Matthew the tax collector was a Jewish man who sat in a toll booth in Capernaum, collecting money from his own people for the government that ruled over them, and that made him a traitor in the eyes of pretty much everyone he grew up with. Then Jesus walked up to his booth and said, "Follow me." The story is in Matthew 9:9-13, and if you grew up in church, you've probably heard it. But I want to slow it down, look at what's going on behind the scenes, and maybe uncover something for all of us who've felt like outsiders. Like we don't belong anymore. Or never did.

Let's start with the context.

Matthew's Gospel was written primarily to a Jewish audience, and that explains a lot of the language and structure you find in it. Think of it as Matthew making a case to his fellow Jews that this Jesus isn't a detour from their story, he's where the story was headed all along. There are echoes of Moses all over the place: Jesus goes up a mountain to teach, Jesus as the new liberator, Jesus bringing a new way forward. You'll even notice Matthew writes "kingdom of heaven" more than thirty times, where Mark and Luke say "kingdom of God." For a long time the standard explanation was reverence, a Jewish way of not overusing the name of God. That's probably part of it. But Matthew still says "kingdom of God" a handful of times, and scholar Jonathan Pennington has made a good case that something bigger is going on. Matthew keeps putting heaven and earth side by side, because God's rule, the one that's already true in heaven, is breaking into this world.

So when we get to chapter 9 and Jesus calls a tax collector, it's not a narrative footnote. It's a disruption, and it challenges everything Matthew's first readers thought they knew about who belongs and who doesn't.

Here is the passage:

As Jesus was walking along, he saw a man named Matthew sitting at his tax collector's booth. "Follow me and be my disciple," Jesus said to him. So Matthew got up and followed him.

Later, Matthew invited Jesus and his disciples to his home as dinner guests, along with many tax collectors and other disreputable sinners. But when the Pharisees saw this, they asked his disciples, "Why does your teacher eat with such scum?"

When Jesus heard this, he said, "Healthy people don't need a doctor, sick people do." Then he added, "Now go and learn the meaning of this Scripture: 'I want you to show mercy, not offer sacrifices.' For I have come to call not those who think they are righteous, but those who know they are sinners." (Matthew 9:9-13, NLT)

On the surface it reads like a simple story. Jesus calls a guy, the guy follows him, and then there's dinner. But if we rush past it, we'll miss the earthquake happening underneath, socially and theologically, and honestly, emotionally too.

Why Was Matthew a Tax Collector?

First, a little world building. Matthew 9:1 says Jesus had just come back to "his own town," which is Capernaum, a fishing village on the north shore of the Sea of Galilee. Capernaum sat close to the border between two territories, so goods coming through got taxed, and that's what Matthew's booth was for. The Greek word is telōnion (τελώνιον), a toll or customs station, and Matthew was a telōnēs, a toll collector. He was probably taxing fish, grain, and whatever else moved through town.

Here's something that's easy to miss. Galilee in Jesus' day wasn't run by a Roman governor (that was Judea, down south). It was ruled by Herod Antipas, a son of Herod the Great, who held his throne because Rome let him. So Matthew worked for Herod, and Herod answered to Caesar. Either way, the money in Matthew's box came out of his neighbors' pockets and went to fund the people who ruled over them. And the rulers usually didn't send their own people to do this. They sold the right to collect to locals, who paid up front and then kept whatever they could collect above what they owed. You can imagine how that went. When tax collectors came to John the Baptist and asked what they should do, his answer was basically, stop taking more than you're supposed to (Luke 3:12-13). And when Zacchaeus met Jesus, the first thing he did was offer to pay people back four times what he'd cheated them out of (Luke 19:8).

So why did Matthew become a tax collector? The Bible never tells us. My guess is it's the same reason most people take a job they know their family won't be proud of. The money was good, and the job was there. But whatever his reasons were, the cost was high. Matthew wasn't just disliked. He was despised. Later rabbis, writing down Jewish law in the Mishnah, lumped tax collectors in with murderers and robbers (m. Nedarim 3:4), and even Jesus uses "tax collectors" as shorthand for the people everyone looks down on (Matthew 5:46, 18:17). It was betrayal wrapped in bureaucracy. Matthew was the enemy from within.

If you've watched The Chosen, you've seen a version of this: Matthew alone in his booth while the people he grew up with can barely stand to look at him. That's not far off.

Mark and Luke tell the same story, but they call him Levi (Mark 2:14, Luke 5:27). Plenty of people in that world went by two names, and that's most likely what's happening here. And there's a detail I love. When Matthew's Gospel lists the twelve apostles, it's the only one that calls him "Matthew the tax collector" (Matthew 10:3). The Gospel that carries his name doesn't hide where he came from.

Why Did Jesus Choose Matthew?

And yet Jesus walks up to that guy and says, "Follow me."

No conditions, no prerequisites, no theological interview or moral reform first. Just an invitation. And Matthew gets up and goes.

That's where it gets personal. Because some of us are carrying a lot of shame. Some of us have been told, out loud or in quieter ways, that we don't belong. Maybe it's because of the questions we ask or the doubts we carry, our politics, what we think about gender roles or sexual ethics, past wounds, current habits. Whatever it is, the church often frames belonging in black and white: you're in or you're out. But here's Matthew, sitting in the messy, complicated gray, and Jesus doesn't flinch. He doesn't draw a line in the sand. He walks right up to it and says, "Come with me."

What happens next is even more surprising. Jesus doesn't take Matthew to the synagogue. He doesn't say, "Great, now that you're following me, come into my world." Jesus goes to Matthew's house (Luke says Levi threw a big banquet for him, Luke 5:29). He enters Matthew's space, sits at Matthew's table, and eats with Matthew's friends.

This is huge. In the ancient world, a meal was never just about food. Who you ate with said something about who you were, and sharing a table with someone was a way of saying you belong with me. So when Jesus eats with tax collectors and "sinners," he isn't just being polite. He's breaking religious protocol on purpose, and he's saying this is where I want to be, with them, at their table.

Side note: "sinners" here doesn't just mean people who sin, because that's all of us. In the Gospels it works more like a social label for people who lived outside the lines of covenant faithfulness. The ones the respectable crowd had already written off.

Of course, this doesn't sit well with the Pharisees. And I want to be fair here, because the Pharisees weren't cartoon villains. They were deeply committed to seeing Israel restored. Many of them believed that if the Jewish people returned to the Torah, if they could just get their spiritual act together, God would come back and rescue them. So they built practices around the Law to help ordinary people stay faithful, and that included being careful about who you shared a table with. But like a lot of institutions, what started as devotion slowly turned into control. The desire to be holy became the justification to judge.

So they see Jesus at this table and they don't understand it. "Why does your teacher eat with such scum?" And Jesus answers with one of the most beautifully subversive lines in Scripture. Healthy people don't need a doctor, sick people do.

Then he tells them to "go and learn," which is how a rabbi sent his students back to the text to do their homework. The text he sends them to is Hosea 6:6, where God says, "I want you to show love, not offer sacrifices. I want you to know me more than I want burnt offerings." The Hebrew word behind "love" there is חֶסֶד (hesed), and it's one of the richest words in the Old Testament. It means loyal love, covenant kindness, the kind of love that shows up and stays. Matthew's Greek renders it eleos, mercy.

Okay, full stop. Jesus is telling the most Bible literate people in town that they've missed the point of their own Bible. God was never after the ritual for its own sake. He was after people whose hearts look like his, hearts that move toward the hurting instead of away from them. Jesus liked this verse so much he quotes it again three chapters later (Matthew 12:7).

That line is everything. Jesus sees himself as a doctor, and a good doctor doesn't avoid sick people. He walks into their room. It's a big part of why I like to talk about Jesus healing us and not only saving us.

Because some of us, maybe even you reading this, are carrying spiritual wounds. You've been made to feel like your questions make you unfaithful. Like your brokenness disqualifies you. Like you're on the outside because you don't fit the system. And maybe you've come to believe that's how Jesus sees you too.

But this story tells a different story. Jesus goes to Matthew before Matthew cleans anything up. He meets him at his table, in the middle of the mess, and he brings healing not by demanding change first but by offering his presence, a relationship, and some dignity.

I resonate with Matthew. I've spent more than two decades in pastoral ministry, trying to faithfully serve communities I love. And yet in this season I've felt pushed out, not because of scandal, but because I'm willing to talk about doubt. Because I make room for questions. Because I don't always land in the theological boxes other people are comfortable with. I drink bourbon and talk about the Bible. I wrestle with women's roles, with how we read Genesis, with whether we've really grasped the story we claim to live by. And for some people, that made me a threat.

So when I read this story, I don't just see Matthew. I feel him. And maybe you do too.

Maybe you're not sure where you belong anymore. Maybe church has become a place of anxiety instead of peace. Maybe you're deconstructing, not because you've lost your faith, but because you're trying to rebuild something more honest. If that's you, I want you to hear this. You are not on the outside of Jesus.

In fact, you may be closer to him than you've ever been. Jesus doesn't wait for the religious system to sign off on you. He comes to your table, pulls up a chair, and says, "Follow me." That's where healing starts. That's where wholeness begins.

So here's something to sit with this week. Where's your booth, the place you're sure Jesus would never walk up to? What if that's exactly where he's headed?

Stories of TOV articles are mine, often adapted from my teaching on Whiskey and the Writings. I use AI tools to help turn transcripts and notes into articles and to check sources. The ideas, convictions, and final edits are mine.

Joe Oliver

Joe Oliver has spent 25 years in pastoral ministry in Boise and holds an M.A. in Biblical Theology. He and his wife Jane lead Stories of TOV and Barstool Theology, and Joe hosts Whiskey and the Writings on YouTube. He's just a guy who loves studying the Bible and making it make sense, especially for people who still believe, just not like they used to.

Read our story


https://storiesoftov.com
Previous
Previous

Is the God of the Old Testament Different from Jesus? Understanding the Full Story of Scripture

Next
Next

Genesis 1 Isn’t About Science—It’s About You