Feeling Spiritually Stuck? What Peter's Worst Night Can Teach You

Most of us know what it feels like to be stuck. Stuck in traffic. Stuck in a job you don't love. But there's a kind of stuck that's harder to talk about, especially if you grew up in church, and if you're reading this, you probably know it. Feeling spiritually stuck is normal. It happens to people who love God deeply, and it is not a sign that you've failed.

It usually looks something like this. The prayers feel like they hit the ceiling. The Bible sits on the nightstand and you can't remember the last time you opened it. The things that used to give you life (worship, Scripture, community) now feel like chores. And somewhere in the back of your mind is a question you don't really want to say out loud. What's wrong with me?

Here is what I have observed. A lot of us were handed a version of faith that only works on the mountaintop. If you're on fire, you're doing it right, and if you're not, something must be off, so you try harder and pray more and read more and show up more. Then the guilt kicks in, shame follows close behind, and a lot of people eventually just walk away.

But what if we've misunderstood how spiritual growth actually works? What if stuck isn't the opposite of growing, but part of it?

A Time for Everything

The best place I know to start is Ecclesiastes, a book a lot of us skipped in Sunday school because it sounds a little depressing. Chapter 3 opens with a poem you've probably heard at a funeral or two.

"For everything there is a season, a time for every activity under heaven." (Ecclesiastes 3:1, NLT)

Then the poem walks through fourteen pairs. A time to be born and a time to die. A time to plant and a time to harvest. A time to cry and a time to laugh. A time to search and a time to quit searching. The Hebrew word for time is עֵת (ʿēt), and in those seven verses it shows up twenty-eight times. You can't miss it. The writer hammers the same idea over and over. Which is that life moves. Nothing stays the same, including your faith.

Side note: Ecclesiastes belongs to what scholars call the wisdom books, along with Job and Proverbs. These books don't hand you formulas. They hand you perspective, and they're trying to help you make sense of life as it actually is, not as we wish it would be.

There's a detail here that's easy to miss. The poem never says you get to choose your seasons. Nobody puts "a time to mourn" on their calendar. A few verses later, the writer says this:

"Yet God has made everything beautiful for its own time. He has planted eternity in the human heart, but even so, people cannot see the whole scope of God's work from beginning to end." (Ecclesiastes 3:11, NLT)

I love how honest that is. Ecclesiastes doesn't promise you'll understand the season you're in. It tells you that it is a season, that God is still at work in it, and that you're only seeing a small piece of a much bigger picture.

Think about a tree in January. No leaves, no fruit, nothing happening. It looks dead. But anyone who gardens will tell you a lot is going on under the ground. The roots are going deeper, and the tree is resting so it can do what it does in spring. A dry season in your faith can look a lot like that from the outside. Like nothing is happening. Fortunately for us, that isn't the whole story.

From "You Are the Messiah" to "I Don't Know Him"

If you want to see a spiritual high and a spiritual crash in the same person, look at Peter, especially Peter in the Gospel of Mark.

In Mark 8, Jesus asks his disciples, "But who do you say I am?" and Peter gets it right. "You are the Messiah" (Mark 8:29, NLT). That's a huge moment. Peter is saying Jesus is God's anointed king, the one Israel had been waiting for. It's a mountaintop.

And it lasts about four verses. Jesus starts explaining that the Messiah is going to suffer and die, Peter pulls him aside to correct him, and Jesus says, "Get away from me, Satan! You are seeing things merely from a human point of view, not from God's" (Mark 8:33, NLT). Dang, that's harsh. Peter had the right title and the wrong picture. He wanted a Messiah who would fix everything, and Jesus had something else in mind.

Then comes the night Jesus is arrested. Peter follows at a distance and ends up in the high priest's courtyard, warming himself by a fire. A servant girl recognizes him, and he denies it. She tells the people standing around, and he denies it again. Then the bystanders press him, and Peter swears he doesn't even know the man. Mark tells us what happened next.

"And immediately the rooster crowed the second time. Suddenly, Jesus' words flashed through Peter's mind: 'Before the rooster crows twice, you will deny three times that you even know me.' And he broke down and wept." (Mark 14:72, NLT)

If you've ever felt like a failure in your faith, Peter gets it.

What I love is that this story made it into the Bible at all. A very early tradition, recorded by a church leader named Papias and preserved by the historian Eusebius, says Mark wrote his gospel from Peter's own preaching. If that's right, then Peter told this story about himself. Probably more times than he could count. He didn't hide his worst night. He made it part of the message.

Jesus Is Not Done With Peter

That isn't where Peter's story ends, though. On Easter morning, the women go to the tomb and find a young man dressed in white who tells them Jesus has risen. Then he gives them a message to carry.

"Now go and tell his disciples, including Peter, that Jesus is going ahead of you to Galilee. You will see him there, just as he told you before he died." (Mark 16:7, NLT)

Including Peter. Two words, and they carry so much. Peter is still on the list.

John's gospel takes it a step further. After the resurrection, Peter goes back to fishing (which is pretty much what all of us do when we're stuck, we go back to what we know). Jesus is on the shore cooking breakfast over a charcoal fire. John uses the Greek word ἀνθρακιά (anthrakia), charcoal fire, only twice in his whole gospel. The first time is the fire Peter stood beside when he denied Jesus (John 18:18). The second is this one (John 21:9).

Are you seeing it yet? Peter is standing at the same kind of fire, and this time Jesus asks him three times, "Do you love me?" Three denials, three chances to say yes. And each time, Jesus hands him a job. "Feed my sheep" (John 21:17, NLT). Peter's failure wasn't the end of him. It turned out to be the beginning of something deeper, and a few weeks later he's standing up in Jerusalem preaching to a crowd (Acts 2).

What to Do When You Feel Spiritually Stuck

So if you're stuck right now, here's what I want you to hear. You are not your current season. This moment is not your whole story.

The next step probably isn't a big one. Maybe it's a whispered prayer in the car. Maybe it's a conversation with a friend who won't try to fix you. Maybe it's opening the Bible to the Psalms without any guilt about how long it's been, even a psalm like Psalm 88 that doesn't end on a happy note. And maybe, honestly, it's just letting yourself be in the season without rushing to get out of it. Elijah needed food and sleep before he needed a sermon.

Over the years, my own walk with Jesus has had incredible highs and humbling lows. I've had seasons where I couldn't get enough of Scripture and others where I couldn't bring myself to open the Bible. I've had days of tearful prayer and days when God felt silent. None of those moments define me. They're part of the journey. Not the whole thing. It hasn't always been easy, but it has been good, which is pretty much what TOV means to me.

So don't measure your spiritual health by a single day, or a week, or even a year. Measure it by your direction. Are you still open? Are you still listening, even if it's faint? That's enough. I'd go as far as to say that's faith.

I don't assume I've answered every question about where God is when your faith feels dry. But I hope you can see yourself in Peter a little bit. The guy who got it right, then got it wrong, then wept by a fire, and then got called by name. Jesus still does that. Not to shame you, but to invite you back into the story. His story.

There is a time for everything, and this season won't last forever. You're not stuck. You're growing.

So what season are you in right now, and what might God be doing under the ground?

Stories of TOV articles are mine, often adapted from my teaching on Whiskey and the Writings. I use AI tools to help turn transcripts and notes into articles and to check sources. The ideas, convictions, and final edits are mine.

Joe Oliver

Joe Oliver has spent 25 years in pastoral ministry in Boise and holds an M.A. in Biblical Theology. He and his wife Jane lead Stories of TOV and Barstool Theology, and Joe hosts Whiskey and the Writings on YouTube. He's just a guy who loves studying the Bible and making it make sense, especially for people who still believe, just not like they used to.

Read our story


https://storiesoftov.com
Previous
Previous

New Testament Study Resources: The Four Books I Reach for First

Next
Next

Is It Reasonable to Believe in a Physical Resurrection?