Was Christianity Ever Unified? How Christian Beliefs Changed Over Time

Most of us like the idea that there was a time when everybody believed the same thing. Somewhere back there, before the denominations and the church splits and the arguments in the comment section, there was one faith held one way by everyone. So was Christianity ever unified? Not in the way many people mean it, as a single, static, fixed, uniform belief system that never changed and never adapted and never moved. When you look honestly at how Christian beliefs changed over time, that version of the story is comforting, and it doesn't hold up against the history.

I want to take you through a thought process I'm still actively sitting with. I don't know that I know exactly where it lands, but I do know it keeps showing up in my reading and in the way I see the Bible functioning as a whole. So I'm going to lay it out as clearly as I can. If it feels like I'm processing out loud in written form, that's because I am.

Here is what I believe. At every point in the history of belief, and at every stage in the formation of what we call the Bible, we are dealing with a culture and a language and a people living at a specific time in a specific place, experiencing God in a specific way. That experience, and the pressures that came with it, shaped how they talked and wrote, and how they gathered and edited this library of texts. And then, after those texts existed, God kept speaking through them into real human beings who were also living in specific places at specific times. Which means belief keeps getting wrestled with, clarified, challenged, refined, and sometimes corrected.

Before somebody hears that and jumps straight to "Joe is turning into a relativist," let me say this as plainly as I can. My theological anchor is Jesus. Systems and tribes and the fear based need to be right all come second to him. I believe the primacy of the Bible, for anyone who wants to live by it, is that it points us to the person of Jesus and invites us to align our lives to his way. I believe truth exists, and I don't believe anything goes. I also believe the story is more complicated than we often pretend it is, and the evidence for that is everywhere once you slow down and look.

I learned pretty early that these kinds of questions make some people nervous. As a young youth pastor I asked a revival speaker a simple question about the Holy Spirit, and his answer was, "Who have you been reading? You need to stop it." I didn't stop. Telling me to stop asking questions is like telling me to start asking more, and the more I read church history, the more I realized the people who came before us were asking hard questions too.

I'm going to walk through a handful of moments across history that make this hard to ignore. I'm not trying to dump a textbook on you. I'm trying to show you a pattern.

Let's start where a lot of people haven't spent much time. The period after the exile.

Most people know the basic outline. Israel goes into exile, Babylon falls to Persia, Cyrus issues his decree in 538 BC, and some of the exiles go home. Jerusalem gets rebuilt, Ezra and Nehemiah show up, and the temple is restored and the walls go back up. End of story.

But that is the story as told from one perspective. And that matters.

When the Persians came to power, they didn't operate the way the empires before them had. Assyria conquered by deporting people and moving new communities in to reshape the land (2 Kings 17:24 describes exactly that). Babylon carried Judah's leading families off to Babylon. Persia had different political instincts. They cared more about stability and local governance than total cultural replacement, so they let deported peoples go home and rebuild their temples. So yes, exiles returned, but not everybody returned. And the land wasn't empty. People had stayed, and worship had kept going.

Now add another layer. Long before Babylon, Assyria had conquered the northern kingdom of Israel in 722 BC. Samaria had been the north's capital since King Omri built it (1 Kings 16:24), and under Assyria its name was applied to the whole province. People remained there too, and new populations mixed in over time. There were still Yahweh worshipers in the north, but their life wasn't centered in Jerusalem. For long stretches Jerusalem was damaged and, for all practical purposes, irrelevant. That kind of vacuum doesn't stay empty. Something always fills it.

In the north, worship and identity eventually gathered around Mount Gerizim, near Shechem. Archaeologists digging on the summit found a sacred precinct built in the middle of the fifth century BC, which means a temple to Yahweh stood on Gerizim during the same years Ezra and Nehemiah were working in Jerusalem. In the south, the memory and hope of Jerusalem remained. By the time the reforms were in full swing, there were competing centers of Yahweh worship and competing visions for what the future should look like.

That is where the story of Ezra and Nehemiah gets more interesting.

The return and rebuilding came in phases. First you have the movement associated with Zerubbabel and Joshua the high priest, focused on the temple, which was finished around 515 BC. Then Ezra arrives with a major emphasis on Torah and reform. Then Nehemiah comes to rebuild the walls and reinforce boundaries. (Side note: scholars still argue about whether Ezra actually came before Nehemiah or after him. The Bible presents them in this order, and that's how I'm telling it.)

That word boundaries matters. What Ezra and Nehemiah were rebuilding went well past walls and gates. They were rebuilding identity and deciding who belonged and who did not. They were trying to shape a people who would not repeat the mistakes of the past. In their minds, mixed and divided worship had led to exile, so the way forward, the way to survive and be faithful, was worshiping Yahweh alone and worshiping him in Jerusalem.

The leaders up north didn't see it that way. Nehemiah's great opponent is Sanballat, the governor of Samaria (Nehemiah 4), and the book even mentions a grandson of the high priest who married Sanballat's daughter, so Nehemiah chased him off (Nehemiah 13:28). These were neighbors, and in some cases relatives, fighting over who got to speak for Yahweh.

Over the next few centuries that northern community became the people we know as the Samaritans. They worshiped Yahweh too. They had the Torah too, in their own edition, which we call the Samaritan Pentateuch. But they didn't accept the prophets and the writings the way the Jerusalem community did, and I don't think that's random. If you reject the prophetic and Davidic traditions, you can reject Jerusalem's claim to be the one true center, because the promise to David is one of the engines driving Jerusalem's restoration.

That is a real conflict, a competition of visions. One group says, we are reforming around Torah and Jerusalem, and we worship Yahweh alone. The other group says, we already worship Yahweh, we already have a center, and we have no interest in surrendering it just because you came back from exile and want to take control again.

The key point is this. The texts we have, Ezra and Nehemiah and the prophets tied to that era, are told from the perspective of the Jerusalem centered reform movement. They don't narrate the full complexity. They narrate what supports their theological aim. I don't think that's malicious, because theological history works that way. It is written with a purpose.

When you see the wider context, though, you realize that even within Yahweh worship, even within what becomes Judaism, there was never a single unified belief system. There were rival temples on rival mountains, and different collections of scripture treated as authoritative.

This is also where you can watch Israel's faith settle into full monotheism. Scholars use the words henotheism or monolatry for worshiping one god as your god while assuming other gods exist. A lot of ancient religion worked that way, and you can see traces of that worldview in Israel's own Scriptures, like the heavenly council in Psalm 82. The push toward Yahweh alone started before the exile with reformers like King Josiah, and the exile sharpened it into a flat claim: "I am the LORD; there is no other God" (Isaiah 45:5). The returnees made that claim a boundary marker.

Already, right there, belief is moving, and the reason is that history happened. Empires rose and fell and the land got reshaped, and the people had to interpret their experience with God inside all of that.

Jump forward to the first century and the center of gravity is Jerusalem again. The temple is there and Rome is in power, and people are longing for liberation and the kingdom of God. The hope of a son of David is alive, and the question on everybody's mind is what God does next.

Even then, Judaism wasn't one thing. The Jewish historian Josephus describes the Pharisees, the Sadducees, and the Essenes as separate schools, and the Greek word he uses for them will sound familiar. Hairesis, αἵρεσις. It means a choice, and from there a school of thought or a party. It's where our word heresy comes from, but for Josephus it just meant a group that chose a particular way of living out the tradition. Luke uses the same word in Acts, when Paul's accusers call him a ringleader of the hairesis of the Nazarenes (Acts 24:5). The followers of Jesus started out as one more "choice" inside a Judaism that already had several. I've written more on what heretic actually means if you want to go down that road.

Jesus steps into that moment and does something that feels familiar if you've been paying attention. He reframes and reworks. He takes what people assumed was fixed and deepens it or challenges it.

You hear it all through the Sermon on the Mount, where Jesus keeps saying some version of "You have heard... But I say" (Matthew 5:21 to 48). With that line Jesus is claiming the authority to interpret Torah and to show people what they had missed. Sometimes he affirms a command and takes it deeper, and sometimes he confronts the way it has been used. But the pattern is consistent. Jesus is moving belief forward.

He reframes the temple too. He speaks of its destruction, and of rebuilding it in a way nobody understands until later. John even tells us that it wasn't until after Jesus was raised from the dead that his disciples remembered what he'd said and believed it (John 2:22). The people closest to him needed a resurrection to understand him.

He even steps right into the old fight between Jerusalem and Gerizim. In John 4 a Samaritan woman brings up the exact argument we just walked through: her ancestors worshiped on this mountain, and the Jews insist Jerusalem is the place. Jesus tells her a time is coming when the Father won't be worshiped on either mountain, and that true worshipers will worship him in spirit and in truth (John 4:20 to 24).

Then Paul takes the disruption even further.

If Ezra and Nehemiah were about reinforcing boundaries, Paul can look like he's tearing them down. Paul cared about holiness, and he also believed God had done something in Jesus that changed the structure of belonging itself. The Gentile question was an earthquake in the early church. Who is included in the people of God, and on what basis? Do Gentiles have to be circumcised and take on Jewish identity markers in order to belong?

Acts 10 to 15 shows you these arguments playing out. Peter has a vision of a sheet full of animals coming down from heaven, the categories of clean and unclean get challenged, and the voice says, "Do not call something unclean if God has made it clean" (Acts 10:15). Peter figures out pretty quickly that this was about more than lunch. A few verses later he tells a house full of Gentiles, "But God has shown me that I should no longer think of anyone as impure or unclean" (Acts 10:28).

Even then it didn't settle cleanly. The leaders in Jerusalem had to meet over it in Acts 15. And Paul tells the Galatians that when Peter came to Antioch and stopped eating with Gentile believers, "I had to oppose him to his face" (Galatians 2:11). Two apostles arguing in public about who gets to sit at the table. I've written more about what that Acts 15 meeting actually meant for Christian unity.

If you only know a version of Christianity where everything was settled from day one, this will mess with you. The early Jesus movement was actively debating what faithfulness looked like in light of what God had done in Jesus. They were wrestling and adapting, reading Scripture in new ways because they believed God was doing a new thing.

Zoom out beyond the New Testament and the same pattern keeps going. As Christianity spread into the wider Greco Roman world, it ran into philosophical categories that Judaism hadn't had to address in the same way. Now the big debates were about who Jesus is. What is his relationship to the Father, and what do we mean when we call him Lord? And how do the Father, the Son, and the Spirit relate to each other?

Those conversations didn't happen in a vacuum. At the Council of Nicaea in AD 325 the key word was homoousios, ὁμοούσιος, which means "of the same substance." It says the Son shares the very being of the Father. That word appears nowhere in the Bible; the bishops took it from the Greek philosophical vocabulary of the day to say something they believed the Bible was already saying. That's Scripture being interpreted in the real world, with the tools and categories people had.

And those debates were messy and political, and they were loaded with power. Nicaea didn't end the argument either. Arianism nearly won, Athanasius was exiled five times for standing against it, and it took the Council of Constantinople in 381 to finish the creed most churches still say today. Then the Council of Chalcedon in 451, trying to describe how Jesus is both fully God and fully human, split the church again. The Coptic, Ethiopian, Armenian, and Syriac churches rejected its wording, and they are still their own family of churches today. Councils happened because people disagreed. Creeds formed because people were drawing lines. Orthodoxy didn't arrive as an obvious package everybody instantly recognized. It formed through conflict and conversation.

Then you get the split between East and West. At a broad level, the Latin speaking West developed along one line and the Greek speaking East along another, with different languages and liturgies, and different ideas about who holds authority. The West increasingly centralized authority around the bishop of Rome, the pope, with a strong claim to succession from Peter. The East emphasized councils and shared leadership among the patriarchs, and it didn't accept a single universal leader in the same way. They also fought over a phrase the West added to the creed, the filioque, which says the Spirit proceeds from the Father "and the Son." Over time those differences became fractures, and in 1054 the fractures became a schism, with the pope's representative and the patriarch of Constantinople excommunicating each other. When crusaders sacked Constantinople in 1204, the break was pretty much sealed.

Both sides appealed to Scripture, and both believed they were preserving the true shape of the church. Unity in the simple sense was never the reality. There was always diversity, disagreement, and development.

Then the Reformation happens, and you get another major shift. Luther was reacting to a real context: indulgence sales, abuses of power, and a system that, in his mind, had drifted from the center and kept ordinary people afraid and anxious about their standing with God. When he posted his Ninety-five Theses in 1517, he pushed back by appealing to Scripture. Rome appealed to Scripture too. The argument was almost always about whose interpretation was faithful, and both sides had a Bible open.

Even within the Reformation you get divergence. Luther and Zwingli met at Marburg in 1529 and could not agree on what happens in the Lord's Supper. Calvin developed his own system. In 1525 a small group in Zurich started baptizing adults, and fellow Christians drowned some of them for it. Baptists, Puritans, and later Methodists came along, and on and on it goes. Now we live in a world with thousands of denominations, and most of them can produce Bible verses to justify why they do what they do.

That should tell you something important. The idea that belief was once fixed and uniform, and then somehow got polluted later, doesn't match the historical record.

Think about your grandma's chili recipe. (Or your grandpa's, if he was the cook.) Everybody in the family makes it, and nobody makes it exactly the same. One aunt adds beans, one cousin swears beans are a crime, and somebody moved to New Mexico and started putting green chile in it. At Thanksgiving every one of them will tell you theirs is the real one, and in a way they're all right, because they're all trying to be faithful to the same grandma. The recipe moved because the people carrying it moved and cooked in different kitchens. What makes it grandma's chili is whether it still tastes like her. For the church, the question is whether it still looks like Jesus.

Okay, full stop. Let me land this in the place that matters most to me.

None of this means nothing matters, or that truth is only relative to culture, or that the Bible has no authority, or that Jesus is just one option among many. This is the heart of my argument. We need to stop pretending that culture is the enemy of faith. Culture has always been part of how faith gets expressed and passed on. The question has never been whether culture influences belief, because it always has. The question is whether our belief is being aligned to the centrality of Jesus, or whether it's being driven by fear, power, and the need to control.

This is where I get blunt. If you claim to follow Jesus but your life doesn't resemble the fruit of the Spirit, you don't look like Jesus. Paul's list, in the same letter where he called out Peter, is pretty clear: "But the Holy Spirit produces this kind of fruit in our lives: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control" (Galatians 5:22 to 23). Those are the evidence of what kind of spirit is shaping you, and none of them are optional extras.

When I'm wrestling with theology, the grid I use is the ethic of Jesus. Is this rooted in love, and does it move me toward loving God and loving my neighbor? Or is it rooted in fear, producing contempt and arrogance and division for the sake of being right?

That's why I can say unity matters and still not lose sleep over the fact that Christians disagree. Paul describes the church as a body: "The human body has many parts, but the many parts make up one whole body. So it is with the body of Christ" (1 Corinthians 12:12). A body only works because its parts are different. Jesus prayed that his followers would be one (John 17:21), and I've come to think what he meant by Christian unity looks like love held together across our differences.

If you've been told the goal is a fixed system you must never question, I want to gently challenge that. The people who gave us the Bible questioned and argued. They lived in real history. Jesus reframed what people thought was settled, and the early church did not have everything instantly locked down.

And I actually think all of this can be good news.

If you're spiritually curious, skeptical, unsure, tired of manipulation and fear based religion, tired of pretending a certainty you don't have, this opens a door. You can be honest, wrestle, grow, and change your mind. You can ask better questions. You can be a person of faith without being trapped in the kind of certainty that gets used as a weapon, or in the idea that mature faith means never changing.

Ask me what I believe right now, and I'll tell you. Ask me again in a month, and I might have learned something that expands it or reframes it. I don't see that as failure, because that's what it means to be a human being learning to trust God in the real world.

My invitation is simple. Keep Jesus at the center and hold your beliefs with humility. Stay rooted in love, and be willing to listen and to admit when things are complicated. And don't be shocked when you discover that the story of belief has always been more human and more grounded in history than the tidy version many of us were handed.

I don't assume I've answered every question about church history here. But if God has always been speaking through texts formed in real history, to real people in real cultures, then it makes sense that he keeps speaking through those texts into our real lives too. The challenge is to keep aligning ourselves to the best way to be human that Jesus reveals and empowers, and to let that shape how we live and how we carry faith forward. There never was a golden age when everybody believed the same thing, and honestly, I'm glad, because it means there's room at the table for your questions too.

So what's one belief you're holding right now that you could hold with a little more humility, and a little more love, this week?

Stories of TOV articles are mine, often adapted from my teaching on Whiskey and the Writings. I use AI tools to help turn transcripts and notes into articles and to check sources. The ideas, convictions, and final edits are mine.

Joe Oliver

Joe Oliver has spent 25 years in pastoral ministry in Boise and holds an M.A. in Biblical Theology. He and his wife Jane lead Stories of TOV and Barstool Theology, and Joe hosts Whiskey and the Writings on YouTube. He's just a guy who loves studying the Bible and making it make sense, especially for people who still believe, just not like they used to.

Read our story


https://storiesoftov.com
Previous
Previous

How Certainty About the Bible Became a Weapon and Why Humility Matters

Next
Next

I Don't Know What to Believe Anymore. Is That Okay?